Skip to content
  • About
  • Partner with Us
  • Press Release Guidelines
  • Op-ed Guidelines
  • Indonesia
Primary Menu
  • Home
  • Latest
  • News
  • Brief
  • Interview
  • Opinion
  • Figure
  • Youth
  • SDGs
  • Topics
  • #LetterfromtheFounder
  • Featured
  • Opinion

The Fall of Indonesia’s Golden Age of Rice

We need powerful and continuous nationwide programs and campaigns to undo hundreds of years of socio-cultural "brainwashing" on rice.
by I Dewa Made Agung Kertha Nugraha July 14, 2022
rice growth process

Historical aspect

Rice has a long history in Indonesia. In the era of kingdoms, rice was an aristocratic food served among kings, brahmins, and notable merchants. During the Dutch colonial period, it was eventually used as a political tool and became food for ordinary people. 

Around 1861-1871, the Dutch colonists noted that rice cultivation in Indonesia was not profitable. This observation was echoed in the book “Rice Cultivation in Java” (1986) by Sajogyo & William L Collier. It stated that the recorded total loss of rice cultivated in 21 cities was worth 5,775 tons of gold. This loss occurred not only due to farmers biting more than they could chew but also to low productivity.

Now, rice has become a part of Indonesian culture as a staple food, and its production is the cornerstone of every presidential regime’s ambitious bid for food security. Every year, the government budgets trillions of rupiah worth of subsidies for fertilizers, seeds, and other agricultural infrastructures such as irrigation and dryers.

Negative impacts

Environmentally, rice might be the most polluting grain, emitting twice as much harmful gases as wheat. For millennia, rice farmers in Indonesia have relied on the practice of flooding paddy fields to stop weeds from growing. However, cultivating rice in flooded conditions generates up to 12% of global methane emissions, a gas blamed for about one-quarter of global warming caused by humans. 

A 2018 analysis from the Environmental Defense Fund revealed that rice farming could have the same short-term damaging effect on global warming as 1,200 coal power plants. The amount is equivalent to the long-term annual carbon emissions from fossil fuels in Germany, Italy, Spain, and the UK combined.

Meanwhile, health-conscious consumers are starting to give up rice for “healthier” carbohydrates with a lower glycemic index to prevent diabetes. 

According to LMC International, in Indonesia, the share of carbohydrate calories from rice decreased up to 10% every year as the income per capita increased from 1961 to 2013. It’s possible that as people get wealthier, they tend to eat more alternative carbohydrates besides rice.

Time to move on

There is a consensus that rice’s per capita consumption will fall over time at the global level. Asia’s contribution to the world rice demand will decrease to 13%, while Africa’s will double from 6% to 15%.

It’s time. We should no longer be so obsessed with the idea of rice as our staple food. Given that rice consumption generally declines as income rises and rice production is environmentally harmful, focusing our food security policy on rice production does not seem to make sense.

Indonesia has various land-based and sea-based food resources. Food diversification is possible and in demand.

What to do

The Indonesian government should allocate more attention and resources to producing other food crops and horticulture. Food security has four main points to be successful: availability, access, utilization, and sustainability.

On food diversification, the government must start from the fundamental: the diversification of land use policy to transform farmers or agribusinesses from a mono-sectoral approach to diverse food farming activities. An example can be seen in Uzbekistan’s 2020 plan to reduce wheat production and enhance other alternative food production.

The next step is on the farm level. We still lack high-quality seeds for alternative food sources. The seed diversification R&D program must be conducted massively. 

To accelerate this effort, the government can open a Public-Private Partnership (PPP) to increase the high yield and affordable subsidized seed program. This program must be promoted based on local wisdom, food preferences, and local food resources every region has.

Another crucial matter is making the harvest products affordable and accessible. The supporting function, especially the logistics, is a serious concern. Data from the Indonesian Cold Chain Association Report in 2019 shows that Indonesia’s cold chain is still underdeveloped. Vegetables and fruits are the major drivers of food loss and surged-price across the supply chain.

To take care of this, the government can create a cold chain & agriculture logistics infrastructure project that should benefit all stakeholders along the value chain. One proposal is to create a holistic wholesale market and logistic center to serve local and external needs. Due to reduced post-harvest losses, this infrastructure will foster the production of horticultural crops and fisheries products.

Lastly, the focus must go to the general public. We need powerful and continuous nationwide programs and campaigns to undo hundreds of years of socio-cultural “brainwashing” on rice. 

We can start from the household level by repromoting the “dining table revolution” campaign on the new public dietary guidelines. These new guidelines can be inserted on various health items, places, and even factory cafeterias.

It is indeed a Herculean task. So, let’s start small!

Editor: Nazalea Kusuma

Thank you for reading!
If you find this article insightful, subscribe to our Weekly Newsletter to stay up-to-date with sustainable development news and stories from multistakeholder communities in the Asia Pacific and beyond.
SUBSCRIBE NOW
I Dewa Made Agung Kertha Nugraha
+ posts

Dewa is the Founder of Indonesia Food Security Review & Setara Agritech. He is also a Research analyst at Carbonesia.

    This author does not have any more posts.

Continue Reading

Previous: How Global Poverty and Hunger Look Like Now
Next: Is the Skill Development of Children and Youth on Track?

Related Stories

a crowd at a stadium concert The Potential and Power of K-pop Fandoms as Global Communities
  • Featured
  • News

The Potential and Power of K-pop Fandoms as Global Communities

by Nazalea Kusuma January 27, 2023
A Japanese giant salamander is lying on top of measuring tape Saving the Japanese Giant Salamander with Sustainable Daisen
  • Featured
  • News

Saving the Japanese Giant Salamander with Sustainable Daisen

by Kresentia Madina January 26, 2023
IKEA’s blue building with a sign that says “IKEA Home" How IKEA Plans to Transition to a Circular Business Model
  • Featured
  • News

How IKEA Plans to Transition to a Circular Business Model

by Kresentia Madina January 25, 2023
greyscale photo of an empty class room Lebanon’s Education Crisis Is Not Getting Better
  • Featured
  • News

Lebanon’s Education Crisis Is Not Getting Better

by Nazalea Kusuma January 24, 2023
a night sky full of stars over kazakhstan’s golden steppe the altyn dala Reviving Kazakhstan’s Prehistoric Ecosystems, the Golden Steppe
  • Featured
  • News

Reviving Kazakhstan’s Prehistoric Ecosystems, the Golden Steppe

by Nazalea Kusuma January 20, 2023
a blue parking sign that reads “Blue badge holders only” indicating designated space for people with disabilities Creating Inclusive and Accessible Public Transportation for All
  • Featured
  • News

Creating Inclusive and Accessible Public Transportation for All

by Kresentia Madina January 20, 2023
  • Latest
  • Popular
  • Partner
  • a crowd at a stadium concert The Potential and Power of K-pop Fandoms as Global Communities
    • Featured
    • News

    The Potential and Power of K-pop Fandoms as Global Communities

  • A Japanese giant salamander is lying on top of measuring tape Saving the Japanese Giant Salamander with Sustainable Daisen
    • Featured
    • News

    Saving the Japanese Giant Salamander with Sustainable Daisen

  • IKEA’s blue building with a sign that says “IKEA Home" How IKEA Plans to Transition to a Circular Business Model
    • Featured
    • News

    How IKEA Plans to Transition to a Circular Business Model

  • greyscale photo of an empty class room Lebanon’s Education Crisis Is Not Getting Better
    • Featured
    • News

    Lebanon’s Education Crisis Is Not Getting Better

  • a night sky full of stars over kazakhstan’s golden steppe the altyn dala Reviving Kazakhstan’s Prehistoric Ecosystems, the Golden Steppe
    • Featured
    • News

    Reviving Kazakhstan’s Prehistoric Ecosystems, the Golden Steppe

  • The green landscape of Semakau Island in Singapore Semakau Island, the Green Landfill in Singapore
    • Featured
    • News

    Semakau Island, the Green Landfill in Singapore

  • Indonesian spices as cultural heritage Enthusiasts Reclaim Spices’ Cultural Heritage, Launch Spice Hub Indonesia
    • Featured
    • News

    Enthusiasts Reclaim Spices’ Cultural Heritage, Launch Spice Hub Indonesia

  • illustration of National SDG tracker by Unescap UNESCAP Supports “Build Back Better” with the National SDG Tracker
    • Featured
    • News

    UNESCAP Supports “Build Back Better” with the National SDG Tracker

  • In frame: Beena Rao with the children | Image source: beenarao.com Beena Rao and Her Fight for Education for the Children of the Slums
    • Figure

    Beena Rao and Her Fight for Education for the Children of the Slums

  • Customized water bottle by Muslimat NU Bojong | Image: Muslimat NU Bojong Muslimat NU of Bojong-Tegal Campaigns Environmental Protection, Reduces Waste Production
    • Featured
    • News

    Muslimat NU of Bojong-Tegal Campaigns Environmental Protection, Reduces Waste Production

  • green big containers, blue building, and large tube at Hamparan project site B-Corp Certified Gree Energy’s Commitments for Food Industry Decarbonization
    • Featured
    • News
    • Partner

    B-Corp Certified Gree Energy’s Commitments for Food Industry Decarbonization

  • the TEPI Talks #4 event poster Media Engagement Workshop for Sustainable Grassroots Movements by Women’s Earth Alliance Indonesia
    • Featured
    • News
    • Partner

    Media Engagement Workshop for Sustainable Grassroots Movements by Women’s Earth Alliance Indonesia

  • Kecak Traditional Dance. | Photo by Aminoz Acid on Unsplash. Bali Grows Arms for Stronger Economic Recovery
    • Brief
    • Featured
    • Partner

    Bali Grows Arms for Stronger Economic Recovery

  • The illustration of Harm Reduction with the fundamental purpose of upholding the safety and dignity of all people. An Introduction to Harm Reduction
    • Brief
    • Featured
    • Partner

    An Introduction to Harm Reduction

  • A young adult from we day ugm and three elementary schoolers planting mangrove seed. Photo is taken from above and shows only their heads and backs. WE Day UGM 2022: Raising Awareness on Climate Change and Encouraging Community Empowerment
    • Featured
    • News
    • Partner

    WE Day UGM 2022: Raising Awareness on Climate Change and Encouraging Community Empowerment

About Us

  • About
  • The Team
  • Partner with Us
  • Sponsored Content
  • Contribute to Our Mission
  • Press Release Guidelines
  • Op-ed Guidelines
  • Advisory Network
  • Youth Advisory Network
  • Author Network
  • FAQ
  • Work with Us
  • Contact Us
  • Terms of Service
  • Privacy Policy
  • FAQ
  • Contact Us
  • Telegram
  • Etsy
  • Tokopedia
  • Media Link 11
  • Media Link 12
  • Media Link 13
  • Media Link 14
  • Media Link 15
© 2023 Green Network Asia